Connect with us

India

Why I.N.D.I.A. Opposing GNCTD (Amendment) Bill, 2023?

The Delhi Ordinance Bill has been tabled in Parliament, and it aims to replace the National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 on the control of services in the National Capital.

Published

on

Bill

Explore the arguments against the bill and gain a comprehensive understanding of its potential impact on the governance of Delhi.

Follow Us

The Delhi Ordinance Bill has been tabled in Parliament, and it aims to replace the National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 on the control of services in the National Capital. The bill has been introduced amid opposition protests, and it proposes to establish a National Capital Civil Services Authority that will recommend the transfers and posting of all Group A officers.

The opposition is not in favor of the GNCTD (Amendment) Bill, 2023 due to concerns over its impact on federalism, democracy, and the autonomy of the Delhi government. They view it as a centralization of power and a reduction in the decision-making authority of elected representatives.

The opposition is not in favor of this Bill:

Assault on federal structure and democracy: The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) has criticized the bill as an assault on India’s federal structure, democracy, and constitution. They argue that the bill centralizes power and undermines the autonomy of the Delhi government.

Opposition views it as “babucracy”: The AAP has accused the government of turning democracy into “babucracy” with this bill. They believe that the bill gives excessive control to bureaucrats and reduces the decision-making power of elected representatives.

Concerns over legislative competence: Some opposition members, such as N. K. Premachandran, have questioned the legislative competence of the government to bring this bill. They argue that the government may not have the authority to introduce such a bill.

Protests and uproar: The introduction of the bill in Lok Sabha has been met with protests and uproar by the opposition. This indicates their strong opposition to the bill and their dissatisfaction with its provisions.

Also read: Opposition Moves No-Confidence Motion Against Modi Government

Here are the top 15 points of the Delhi Ordinance Bill:

  1. The Delhi Ordinance Bill aims to replace the National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023.
  2. The bill proposes to establish a National Capital Civil Services Authority
  3. The National Capital Civil Services Authority will recommend the transfers and posting of all Group A officers
  4. The bill seeks to provide for the proper functioning of the government of the National Capital Territory of Delhi
  5. The bill proposes to amend the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi Act, 1991
  6. The bill seeks to clarify the powers of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi
  7. The bill proposes to give more powers to the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi
  8. The bill seeks to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor is kept in the loop on all matters related to the administration of Delhi
  9. The bill proposes to give the Lieutenant Governor the power to make rules
  10. The bill seeks to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor is consulted before any executive action is taken by the Delhi government
  11. The bill proposes to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor’s opinion is sought before any decision is taken by the Delhi government
  12. The bill seeks to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor’s approval is obtained before any decision is taken by the Delhi government
  13. The bill proposes to give the Lieutenant Governor the power to refer any matter to the President of India
  14. The bill seeks to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor is kept informed about all matters related to the administration of Delhi
  15. The bill proposes to give the Lieutenant Governor the power to call for any information related to the administration of Delhi

What are the arguments in favor of the Delhi Services Bill:

The Delhi Services Bill has been introduced in Lok Sabha amid opposition protests. Here are the arguments in favor of the Delhi Services Bill:

Clarity: The Delhi Services Bill aims to provide clarity on the roles and responsibilities of the Delhi government and the Lieutenant Governor. This is expected to help in the smooth functioning of the government and improve governance.

Empowerment of Delhi Government: The Bill is expected to empower the Delhi government to take decisions on matters related to services such as health, education, and transport. This is expected to help the government in implementing its policies effectively.

Constitutional: The Bill is constitutional and is based on the Supreme Court’s acknowledgment of Parliament’s superior authority to legislate for the national capital.

Support from Government: The government has supported the Bill, with Union Minister of State for Culture Meenakshi Lekhi stating that the Opposition was trying to mislead the public over the Delhi Services Bill.

Opposition Criticism: The criticism of the Bill by the opposition has been described as political by Home Minister Amit Shah.

What are the arguments against the Delhi Services Bill?:

The Delhi Services Bill has been a topic of controversy in India, with arguments both for and against it. The following are some arguments against the bill:

Violation of Separation of Powers: All India Majilis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen chief Asaduddin Owaisi opposed the bill saying it violates the theory of separation of power.

Weakening of Federal Structure: The parties of the opposition’s INDIA bloc opposed the Bill, noting that it is aimed at weakening the country’s federal structure.

Undermining Delhi Assembly: Congress leader Shashi Tharoor argued that the bill undermines the Delhi assembly and the Supreme Court judgment.

Controversial: The Delhi Services Bill is controversial and has been described as such by various news outlets.

Opposition Protests: The introduction of the Bill in Lok Sabha was met with opposition protests.

In summary, the Delhi Ordinance Bill proposes to establish a National Capital Civil Services Authority and clarify the powers of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi. The bill seeks to ensure that the Lieutenant Governor is kept in the loop on all matters related to the administration of Delhi and is consulted before any executive action is taken by the Delhi government. The bill also proposes to give the Lieutenant Governor more powers, such as the power to make rules and refer any matter to the President of India.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *